Decision Points

     A circumspect George W. Bush appeared on NBC with Matt Lauer reviewing the major difficult decisions of his consequential presidency on 11/08/10 recounted in his new book Decision Points which opened today on Amazon.com at #1.  It is no surprise to anyone that the former president states on multiple occasions that personal popularity meant little to him in determining the course of major policy decisions.  In a strange way it seems to be almost a source of pride to him that often the tough decisions seemed to be generally unpopular ones.  The tide of history certainly exposed his presidency to more than the usual profound moments and for the most part I think he believes he stayed true to the ” right course” for the country.

     The pivotal moment was clearly 9/11 and on this pinnacle of crisis essentially all of his decisions radiate outward.  His explanation for the emotion that formed a backdrop to his speech on the world trade center rubble is a riveting piece of history.  Almost as wrenching is President Bush’s description of the burden of serving as commander in chief in consequential times resulting in the deaths of over 4000 servicemen.  He relates the story of the Chapman family, who he met at a service for their fallen son among many others.  President Bush noted that after the service, Mrs. Chapman brought him a note that read,  ” My son did his duty, now go and do yours,”  a buckling, emotional moment.  His visible attachment to the memory serves as an undeniable view into the sincerity of his motivations in the actions he took.  President Bush sleeps well at night with his conviction that what he did was in the service of his country’s best interests and security.

     Equally interesting is the focus on the Hurricane Katrina natural disaster.  The former president is clear that the perception of the national government refusing to provide troop support and security was a false one.  The governor of Louisiana and  the mayor of New Orleans dithered for days on whether to invite in federal troops, and the president was hamstrung  without a state invitation.  The federal government would have had to declare an insurrection to put in the military without an invitation and that would have clearly led to an explosive situation.  He is clear, also, in his contribution to the sense of presidential detachment to the tragedy, and admits it almost single handedly brought his functional presidency to an end in the public purview of him as a leader.   Not one of his finer moments, and certainly not one of Louisiana’s.

     The consensus of the interview is the sense of the former President that he did his best and did what he thought was right.   It is certainly a presidency that will require more than a few years to absorb the extended impact of George W. Bush’s decision making.  On so many fronts, from defining western civilization’s response to the violent challenge of radical Islam, to the introduction of elemental democratic freedom to the autocratic Middle East, to destructive assault on free market mechanisms in the TARP legislation in order to “save’ them,  and surviving the closest election in American history with the capacity to lead intact, this has proved to be one consequential presidency, and one consequential man.

Ramparts Holiday

     To the loyal defenders of the ramparts, a few days of retrenchment is in order before the next post.  Until then, please feel free to peruse and enjoy previous posts, and this brief wonderful reminder of a government over-invested in your life.  Daily Ramparts will return soon!

Tsunami

     Maybe the most frightening moment of an incoming tsunami is when the sea, wrenched by enormous under water forces, pulls back from the land mass, and a momentary still pervades the beach.  The sense of being safe, on dry land,  is overwhelmed by the dread of the unforeseen but inexorable wave surge to come.  Waiting for inevitable destruction can be psychologically unbearable.  

     So must it have been for the democrat party nation in the state of Wisconsin on the eve of November 2nd.  In a wave of voter impact unique in its focused destruction, the democrat party lost the Governorship, the available U.S. Senate seat, the Assembly, the Senate, and control of the U.S. House delegation.  Swept away in the tide was the heart of the democrat leadership, the 18 year so called maverick U.S. Senator, the Leader of the state House, and the Leader of the State Senate.  The aftermath of the wave is a blue state now emblazoned bright red, and the shore line in just one day is unrecognizable.

      The election Tsunami of 2010 proved to be every bit as ferocious as advertised and the consequences of such a complex wave will be felt for years to come. Beyond the state of Wisconsin, some very interesting aspects of the surge deserve Ramparts acknowledgement and circumspection:

           Rise of the Black Conservative 

The election of Representatives Tim Scott from the 1st district of South Carolina and Colonel Allen West from Florida’s 22nd district with solid victories in  white majority districts are indications of a new type of African American politician – strongly conservative, fierce defenders of individual responsibility and endeavor , small government, and most at home in the Republican Party.   Since the 1960’s and the association however unfair of the democrat party with civil rights legislation and societal safety nets has lead to election after election of greater than 90% support for the democrat ticket in the black community and the subsequent effect on districting and policy of democrats.  A rising middle and upper middle class black voter is beginning to result in cracks in the homogeneous voting pattern, as more and more focus is paid to the four decade effect of the juxtaposition of singular loyalty to the democrat party by blacks and the state of the  black family, economic and educational opportunity, and relative progress compared to other ethnic groups.  Representatives Scott and West may prove to be leaders in a more circumspect evaluation of liberal policies on the African American community and a more competitive argument for their future voting power.

          Woe Be Gone California    

The tsunami stopped at the border of California. Liberal democrats Governor Brown and Senator Boxer cruised to easy victories  as the California voter proved oblivious to the state of California’s precarious position as a debtor government in severe economic peril, with crushing mandates and uncontrolled immigration imperiling its very existence.  The voter seemed to hope that the state is simply to big to fail, and if it does fail, will be too destructive to the rest of the nation’s economy for the rest of the country to let it happen.  Here’s the bad news California.   After the outrage over the TARP and Fannie and Freddie May mortgage bailouts, you’re likely to be on your own in this mess. Good luck , Governor Brown.   

          The Rust Belt Goes From Blue to Red

The Midwest has sustained a devastating direct hit from the recent recession and has been woefully ill equipped to respond to the economic triple indemnity of high taxes, union driven state budgets and fleeing of traditional manufacturing jobs to more receptive states with better business environments.  The rust belt voter said Enough! yesterday with the election of republican governors in Wisconsin, Michigan, Ohio, and Iowa and the almost complete takeover of state legislatures by the Republican party.  This will have profound effects on state economic structures, political re-districting,  and business climate likely to be felt for years to come.  Any effect on national strategic directions?  Remember, of the 44 American presidents, 15 have come from the Midwest.

          Government driven Healthcare Mandates doomed Its Supporters to Political Oblivion

The American public was uniform in its distaste for so-called Obamacare.  The attraction of an idea of an over arching healthnet provided for citizens by their government paled in comparison to the perception of people with good coverage as to what the effect would be on them personally.  The progressive elevation of premiums in direct response to Obamacare mandates after assurance that the effect of nationalization of health coverage would have the opposite effect, was devastating to Obamacare supporters in legislative elections, and time and time again proved to be their elective downfall.

           The Rising Stars

There have been few elections in recent history where so many potential stars have been put forward by electoral success.  Much has been through the power of the Internet, allowing the viral video to expose to the general public obscure elections and the talent pool that the Republicans had to draw from this time.  The list is truly amazing in the depth of the talent bench.  Look in the future for the significant impact of such rising stars as Marco Rubio and Allen West of Florida; Tim Scott and Nikki Haley of South Carolina; Scott Walker, Paul Ryan, Ron Johnson, and  Sean Duffy of Wisconsin; Rob Portman of Ohio; Kristi Noem and John Thune of South Dakota – a deep bench with other players soon to be prominent to defend the cause of constitutionalist government and individual freedom.

              United States Constitution Has Legs

The single driving force of all this change has been the undeniable love of a people for their country’s document of foundation, the Constitution of the United States.  The progressive inattention to the principles expressed in the Constitution by politicians who either had no understanding of the tenets of the Constitution or who felt those tenets to be passe or no longer relevant, met with a tremendous backlash from the voting public.  It is clear to all that the overriding lesson of this election is that the American voting population is not ready to eject Constitutional principles of government and the relation of the government with its people expressed in the Constitution for  some on the fly interpretation.  In the end, the American nation felt it had come too far and accomplished to much, to throw out the philosophical driving force of the American Experience.

To which, I say to the American people…..thank you from the bottom of my heart.

Democracy: A Beautiful Thing

     At 700 am this morning I participated in one of the really arcane processes still existing, and felt that old special shiver down my spine. Standing in a line of a hundred, waiting for some octogenarian to find my name visually on a printed scroll of names, handed a piece of paper in which I entered a cardboard stand, took a pen and filled in the little circle in front of the representative of my choice, and put it in a ballot box- well, I’ll tell you, it doesn’t get any better than that. Thousands of people like me joined philosophical hands today in that all too underrated process of committing an act of democracy. It doesn’t matter so much about the choices, really, though this year the opponents stood in especially stark contrast. It is more the individual act of leaving your mark and determining ,in a very specific step, the direction of the country for the next two years.

     One wonders if the Greeks of Athens, inventing Demokratia in the 5th century BC felt the same tingle. It took more than an ID card even then, with only a small portion of the populous able to register as citizens and initiate the act of democracy, literally “rule by the governed”. Did they feel the same pride of ownership of their vote, their capacity to effect change in their leaders and in the leaders’ philosophies? I suspect so. We are very jaded in modern society in our “inability ” to influence events, but this is really a facade covering our laziness and lack of organizational discipline. A “tea party” this year formed out of thin air, and in the space of one year has managed to stop a political movement in its tracks and potentially assist in the birth of another, proving for all to see, that changing political directions, like losing weight, is simply a matter of enthusiasm and sustained discipline.

     Not matter how the election of 2010 turns out, I will be greatful for playing a very small, but pivotal part of it, the part of participation in my country’s future. The world over, that’s a beautiful, beautiful thing…